Phillip J. Rotella Memorial Golf Course

Course Details

Phillip J. Rotella Memorial Golf Course

Phillip J. Rotella

100 Thiells Mt Ivy Rd
Thiells, NY 10984-1443

(845) 354-1616

Regulation

Municipal Facility

Just Golf

18

1987

Michael R. Laudien

Hal C. Purdy/Stephen Kay

$72 weekend
$60 weekday
$46 twilight

71.4

6502

72

Blue

Blue

Get a Handicap
CLUB NAME ACTIONS
USGA Handicap Index
Reviews
  Clubhouse / Facilities Avg. Rating:
  Quality of Course Avg. Rating:
  Value for the Money Avg. Rating:
  Overall Rating Avg. Rating:
Overall Rating 4 out of 5 based on 82 user reviews
Review Date Member Overall Rating
09/12/21
Nice spot
Review Date Member Overall Rating
09/08/21
Nice views of the mountains..course in good shape..
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/27/21
Excellent course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/24/21
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/25/21
Beautiful course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/13/21
Decent course, not the best maintained but very solid course with some fun holes
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/06/21
So so
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/31/21
Great course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/02/21
Excellent course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
11/08/20
Beautiful course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
10/11/20
Great snacks
Review Date Member Overall Rating
09/06/20
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/15/20
Nice
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/31/20
Great
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/15/20
I’m great shape
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/03/20
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/15/20
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/14/20
Great course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/10/20
HILLY but in great condition
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/08/20
Great greens!
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/11/20
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/29/19
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/18/19
First time playing this course and I truly enjoyed it. The course was in amazing shape.
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/03/19
Loved it
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/29/19
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/27/19
Great public course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/21/19
Great condition despite heavy rain all week
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/03/19
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/01/19
Nice course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/15/19
Excited for regionals!!!
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/04/19
Decent
Review Date Member Overall Rating
11/25/18
Awesome for the price. Best pro in the section. Mike Laudine is the best
Review Date Member Overall Rating
09/30/18
Good
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/31/18
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/31/18
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/10/18
Greens were in great shape
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/07/18
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/01/18
Liked it
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/10/18
x
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/03/18
Review Date Member Overall Rating
04/09/18
Review Date Member Overall Rating
03/24/18
Review Date Member Overall Rating
11/19/17
It’s okay
Review Date Member Overall Rating
10/12/17
Hilly and nice course.
Review Date Member Overall Rating
09/09/17
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/09/17
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/31/17
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/29/17
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/14/17
Review Date Member Overall Rating
10/20/16
Good condition
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/19/16
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/15/16
Tight and hilly.
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/09/16
Nice course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
09/29/15
Great course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/17/15
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/15/15
Good.
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/15/15
Good
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/04/15
Not great course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/04/15
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/04/15
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/02/15
Dd
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/20/15
Great!
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/27/15
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/12/15
b+
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/01/15
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/23/15
not a easy course, good tee off shot need.
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/03/15
air raided greens but good conditions otherwise
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/12/14
Good
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/07/14
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/30/14
Very picturesque course with a nice layout. Lots of bunkering and some challenging pin positions made for an interesting round of golf. My biggest complaint was the condition of the greens, which had a lot of ball marks and foot prints. Also it was a 5hr round and I didn't see any marshals, and this was on a Sun. This course has great potential but needs healthier greens and leveled tee boxes to be better.
Review Date Member Overall Rating
04/10/14
good
Review Date Member Overall Rating
10/31/13
Nice greens
Review Date Member Overall Rating
08/10/13
Nice course, great value.
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/04/13
I just cant find any redeeming qualities for the course, the layout is marginal, it never seems to be in good shape and there is nothing that can really be said for the cost of this course there are many other courses in the area that are far superior. The course isnt unfair to play but it has no redeeming qualities unless you want to play an inexpensive course with grass.

Very backed up and they dont care, we had three foursomes waiting at every hole and even though we called the pro shop to inform them of slow play, nothing was done about it. Yes great scenery little challenge besides poorly laid out holes.

Been playing for 38 years and wouldnt waste my money here again
Review Date Member Overall Rating
04/24/13
Review Date Member Overall Rating
04/13/13
Yes
Review Date Member Overall Rating
11/18/12
Tough
Review Date Member Overall Rating
09/25/12
Tough course
Review Date Member Overall Rating
07/29/12
z
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/29/12
Fab muni
Review Date Member Overall Rating
05/14/12
Decent muni
Review Date Member Overall Rating
06/24/11
zteh
Recent Scores
MEMBER SCORE RT/SL PLAYED
BSL 95 72.1/134 10/16/21
Lee81 87 71/132 10/15/21
mkim1397 86 71/132 10/13/21
piegolfer 79 67.9/124 10/13/21
kenk201 88 70.4/131 10/12/21
piegolfer 82 67.9/124 10/06/21
kennyk0315 85 72.1/134 10/03/21
kenk201 85 70.4/131 10/01/21
piegolfer 82 67.9/124 09/29/21
Brandon4420 87 72.1/134 09/25/21
kenk201 89 70.4/131 09/23/21
bigdlittled 88 70.4/131 09/14/21
Crayman 91 71.5/132 09/11/21
kenk201 80 70.4/131 09/09/21
piegolfer 80 67.9/124 09/08/21
BPJgolfs 86 71/132 08/30/21
rrielly13 86 70.4/131 08/27/21
jherzog 91 70.4/131 08/25/21
kenk201 79 70.4/131 08/17/21
Brandon4420 84 72.1/134 08/14/21
mkim1397 89 72.1/134 08/10/21
jmeier1 103 72.1/134 08/09/21
Cadillac14 84 72.1/134 08/08/21
BPJgolfs 92 72.1/134 08/08/21
BobbySlice 98 71.5/132 08/04/21
Scorecard
Course Tee Gender Rating Slope
Philip J. Rotella Municipal Golf Course Blue M 72.1 134
Philip J. Rotella Municipal Golf Course White M 70.4 131
Blue/White M 71.0 132
Gold M 67.9 124
Red/White M 65.3 116
White/Blue M 71.5 132
Gold W 72.6 122
Red W 67.5 114
White W 75.2 126
Map
Course Photos
Be the first to tag a photo of Phillip J. Rotella Memorial Golf Course here.
Weather